Who Is Your "Off-Campus" Boyfriend Based on Your Zodiac Sign?

Elle Kennedy’s The Deal stole readers' hearts all the way back in 2015. Now, the first book in the bestselling Off-Campus series has finally gotten its perfect TV adaptation with the Prime Video series airing right now. Along with the show, a whole new wave of internet boyfriends has officially taken over everyone's FYP.

While Season 1 locks in on the fake-dating romance between Hannah Wells (Ella Bright) and Garrett Graham (Belmont Cameli), it also introduces us to the three other key players on the Briar University starting lineup: Dean Di Laurentis (Steven Kalyn), John Logan (Antonio Cipriano), and John Tucker (Jalen Thomas Brooks). They are all hockey stars, total heartthrobs, and best friends-turned-roommates—but their personalities couldn't be more different. And that means their ideal matches look completely different, too.

Let's be real: you probably already have a favorite picked out in your head. But if your watch parties with friends are turning into chaotic debates over who is truly Number One, take a deep breath. All you need to do is look to the stars to find out which Off-Campus guy is cosmically destined to be your main character.

🔥 If you're a Fire sign (Aries, Leo, Sagittarius)

Your ideal guy: John Logan (or just Logan)

Book fans often claim that Logan is a Sagittarius, and honestly, it’s easy to see why. He’s easygoing, fun, optimistic... and maybe a little reckless when it comes to love (which you'll definitely see in upcoming seasons)—all classic Sag traits.

As a Fire sign, your vibrant, magnetic vibes completely match his energy. Your shared chaotic-but-cute spontaneity means this relationship would be anything but boring.

🪵 If you're an Earth sign (Taurus, Virgo, Capricorn)

Your ideal guy: Dean Di Laurentis

In Season 1, Dean steps into a secret fling that quickly morphs into the ultimate "he fell first and harder" trope with Allie Hayes. Since a lot of fans vibe with Allie having major Capricorn energy, Dean is basically universe-certified for Capricorns (and Earth signs) who love to watch a reformed playboy completely lose his mind over a girl.

Just like Allie, you’re ambitious, dependable, and low-key craving a cozy sense of stability. Dean’s fierce loyalty and hidden emotional depth will check all your boxes, while his life-of-the-party energy guarantees you’ll remember to let your hair down and just have fun. And don't worry—his playboy era is officially over.

💨 If you're an Air sign (Gemini, Libra, Aquarius)

Your ideal guy: John Tucker (or just Tucker)

This ultimate "golden retriever" guy won everyone's hearts with his gentle, protective care and his role as the low-key "house mom" (giving major healthy Taurus or Cancer traits). This is exactly what a free-spirited and independent Air sign needs to feel safe and completely grounded.

Someone definitely needs to check Tucker's natal chart, because he brings some major air-sign energy to the table himself: he’s laid-back, absolutely hates drama, and always goes out of his way to make sure everyone around him is comfortable (pure Libra vibes!). Honestly, your souls speak the exact same language.

💧 If you're a Water sign (Cancer, Scorpio, Pisces)

Your ideal guy: Garrett Graham

Garrett Graham is the only Briar University guy for you. Fans unanimously agree that the main character, Hannah, is a textbook Cancer, making Garrett a 100% match for other Water signs. He is an incredible listener, which perfectly complements your emotional depth and introspective nature.

Even if you guard your heart at first and keep him at a distance, you’ll quickly realize that Garrett is your safe harbor. He is fiercely protective of the people he loves, bringing unwavering loyalty and a genuinely kind heart to the table. You two are quite literally a match made in heaven.